Choice of First Dog Is Narrowed to 2 Breeds

First Dog finalistsPresident-elect Barack Obama said that his family is choosing between a Labradoodle, left, and a Portuguese water dog. (Phil Marino; Gordon M. Grant for The New York Times)

The Obamas are nearing a decision on one of the most closely watched appointments of the new administration: the breed of the First Dog.

As President-elect Barack Obama prepared to appear on ABC’s Sunday morning show, “This Week,” the Obama girls, Malia, 10, and Sasha, 7, who had joined him in the studio, asked the host George Stephanopoulos to slip the following question into his interview: “What kind of a dog are we getting and when are we getting it?”

Mr. Obama laughed when he got the question. “They seem to have narrowed it down to a Labradoodle or a Portuguese water hound,” he said. The next step, he said, was to canvass shelters to see if they could find one of those breeds as a rescue.

“We’re closing in on it,” he said, adding, “This has been tougher than finding a Commerce secretary.” New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson, Mr. Obama’s original nominee for the post, recently dropped out, citing a federal “pay-to-play” investigation into his administration.

The identity of the First Pooch is just one of the many personal issues facing the First Family as it settles into Washington. Mr. Obama said that the family was also planning to visit a number of churches to find one they found comfortable — a challenge, in part, because of the inevitable entourage of security and press that will accompany them to worship services. The Obamas also announced Friday that Michelle Obama’s mother, Marian Robinson, 71, will be moving into the White House.

One family matter that seems to be hitch-free is the transition of the girls to their new Washington private school, Sidwell Friends.

“They seemed to thrive,” Mr. Obama said of their first week at the school. “I’m trying to figure out why it is that they don’t seem to be fazed by anything. People think — you know, folks think I’m cool. They are a lot cooler than I am. They just don’t seem to be intimidated.”

As has been widely discussed, Malia, 10, is allergic to dogs, so the Obama family has been focusing its search on breeds with the reputation of being easier on those with allergies.

Though no dog is 100 percent non-allergenic, some breeds shed less than others, and therefore release less dander — the cause of common dog allergies.

The Portuguese water dog, which doesn’t shed, is among the breeds the American Kennel Club recommends for those with allergies. A seafaring breed that has been known for centuries along the Portuguese coast, “it was prized by fishermen for a spirited, yet obedient nature, and a robust, medium build that allowed for a full day’s work in and out of the water,” the Kennel Club writes on its Web site.

Kennedy

Once used for tasks like carrying messages between boats in the water, it is considered highly intelligent and has either curly or wavy hair. And it has an added endorsement: Senator Edward M. Kennedy owns two Portuguese water dogs, Sunny and Splash. The two dogs frequently flank him as he walks through the halls of the United States Capitol. And Splash, an apparent genius, is also credited by the Senator with ‘writing’ a 2006 children’s book, “My Senator And Me: A Dog’s Eye View Of Washington, D.C.”

The Labradoodle, meanwhile, is a created, or designer, breed: a cross between a Labrador retriever and a poodle. Originally the brainchild of an Australian breeder who needed a service dog for a visually-impaired woman whose husband had dog allergies, it is now bred around the world. Its temperament is “clever, sociable, comical, joyful, energetic when free and soft and quiet when handled,” according to the Web site of the Australian Labradoodle Association of America.

The Labradoodle’s top endorsement may well be from Vice President-elect Joseph R. Biden Jr., who is reported to own a Labradoodle named Brother. On the other hand, the Labradoodle is not among those dogs recommended by the Kennel Association for allergy sufferers because of its status as a designer breed.

“‘Designer dogs,’ often mixed with poodles, are not recommended for allergy suffers due to their unpredictable coat,” the Kennel Association wrote in a recent news release posted on its Web site when the Obama dog search became known. “There is no way to guarantee a litter will produce puppies with equal Poodle coats, making the high prices unjustifiable and the claims of these dogs being ideal misleading at best.

“A ‘designer dog’ lacks the predictability and could pose a problem for Obama’s allergy-suffering daughter,” the release says.

Notably absent from the shortlist of First Dog candidates was the goldendoodle, a cross between a golden retriever and poodle. While campaigning in Iowa in 2007, Mr. Obama had said that the goldendoodle was Malia’s top choice. There was no word from Mr. Obama on why the goldendoodle had withdrawn from consideration, though it seems a safe bet that, in this case, a federal investigation was not the cause.

Ashley Southall contributed research from Washington.

Comments are no longer being accepted.

I hope the Obamas will choose a rescue dog. It would do wonders for the thousands of dogs languishing in shelters.

I expect the goldendoodle disappeared because Sasha met the Kennedy and Biden dogs. If they knew someone with a standard poodle, it would be on the list.

I can strongly recommend a poddle mix. Had one as a kid – non-intentional. Mom was a rescued standard poodle. Litter was sort of unexpected (in the day before mandatory neutering of any rescued dog.) This dog had the coloring of a shepard (like a Tibetan Mastiff) and more of that muzzle shape (the shepard). Hair was silky smooth. Hindquarter was more square like a poodle’s but some of the angulation as a shepard. Had the webbing between the toes (probably from the poodle side.)

Smart as a whip. Protective. Loved all kids, but had a voice to scare the toughest. (probably would have knocked them out by the tail, but probably would have used the bite if instructed to.) Endurance to beat the band but also a good sprinter. Developed as a jumper too (those frisbee catches at the height of the toss.)
And, yes, very obedient.

My family adopts animals strictly from rescues (we have five rescued cats, and two rescued dogs) and really, we haven’t regretted it at all. Some people want to own the puppy, but really the dogs that we’ve rescued have been sweeter for the most part than any dog that we’ve bought as a puppy, and we’ve never had an unfriendly puppy.

The boxer should be top of the list. Great with kids, clean, smart, fun and handsome. Definitely a breed worthy of being the first dog. A rescue boxer, such as a white boxer, would be great. A boxer is a dog that the girls would love and the President would feel proud to be pictured with a boxer.

The Porti is a hard working breed. They are robust, strong, loyal, fun, gorgeous. It would be a great message to have such an ambassador. For health allergy reasons the Porti would be the best choice. They are also the cutest puppies though mouthy. The nation would fall in love with it.

all purebred dogs are “designer” dogs. The AKC hasn’t recognized these breeds, and makes all kind of claims about how “unpredictable” some trait is of any non-recognized breed. This is to encourage everyone in the world to keep buying over- and in-bred animals with genetic problems, which makes money for the AKC and it’s membership.
The problems are definitely “predictable”. If you have a dachshund, it will likely end up with back problems, if you have a bulldog, it will have nasal problems, if you have a german shepherd, it will have hip problems, if you have a pekingese, it’s eyes will fall out…

Having just adopted two rescue dogs this week, i can tell you that the shelters are filled with designer dogs and top breeds such as the Obamas are looking for. you’d be amazed at the wonderful dogs available… pure breeds as well as mixed. Dogs that are considered high priced and rare are found beside the everyday mixes that used to fill the shelters. I’m sure with some diligence the Obama family will find just the dog they are looking for at a rescue or shelter.

Too bad it’s not going to be a standard poodle. Mine, named Maddie, is a superb dog. She’s beautiful, athletic (can jump almost 4 ft. straight up), smart and is a non-barker. She’s patient, very friendly and loves to play. My only complaint, if it really is one, is that when I don’t want to play, she will gently nip my butt.

Something tells me that uncle Teddy has a gift waiting for the girls.

Here’s a rescue group for Portuguese Water Dogs on Yahoo Groups: //pets.groups.yahoo.com/group/PWDadoption/?v=1&t=search&ch=web&pub=groups&sec=group&slk=5

There is a rescue group for every pet and animal on this planet. The only question for the Obamas is whether there is a dog available for rescue that meets their needs, nearby enough. A purebred animal adopted from a rescue situation is just as saved as one adopted from an animal shelter.

Designer Dogs are 2009’s renaming for plain old Mutts. I had a cockadoodle when I was 9. He cost 50$ as he was an “accident.” In other words, a pet and a stray got it on. I can’t believe people are falling for this designer dog sam.

nc #6 is absolutely correct – my friends have over the years rescued several dogs, including two Mastiffs and a Spinone, which were abandoned in state parks near NYC.

Often an apartment dweller has a dog that turns out to be big or too much repsonsibility, needs too much exercise, or is just too expensive to keep. (I wish everyone gave as much consideration to pet ownership at the Obama family displays.)

Whichever breed they choose, it will be the most popular breed for a while and the puppy mills are sure to follow. There isn’t much they can do about that except to talk about responsible pet ownership as much as they can.

Peronally I abhor the term “designer dog” and would really, really prefer if people would call them what they are- mixed-breed dogs. “Designer dog” is nothing more than a marketing term that allows unscrupulous pet dealers to sell poorly bred animals for hundreds of dollars, while thousands of other mixed breed dogs wait for the needle in shelters. (Just for clarification, “poorly bred” refers to the abysmal conditions in the large-scale breeding operations known as puppy mills, and nothing to do with the ancestry of the dog. Mutts ROCK!)

On that note, KUDOS to the Obama family for making adoption their first option!!!! I hope that their decision sets a trend… and I really hope that the media chooses to play up the RESCUE aspect more than the type of dog finally chosen. I can’t express my gratitude enough for that kind of attention in the animal welfare community. Best of luck with your new buddy, Obamas!

Definitely a rescued dog s the way to go!!!!…no matter what breed!….for everybody!

comments like #13 and #14 from – B are well thought and well researched. Lots of pets of all types and variety can be found for anyone willing to take the time to look. I hope someone from the Obama camp is reading this thread and uses these two postings wisely as they would have a huge impact on the many pets who find themselves abandoned every year.

ps – gus looks really cute: //www.petfinder.com/petnote/displaypet.cgi?petid=12753920

The Obama girls should not have to worry the political statement their new dog will make.Their family has made so many sacrifices for our country already.

At least let them pick whatever dog, rescue or designer or not, that they want.

excerpts from a report on NPR:

Finding the perfect pup could be tricky, the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology contends, because there is no such thing as a hypoallergenic breed.

Shaggy dogs often get a bum rap, but allergens are actually in skin, not hair, the academy explains. The amount of allergen dander varies drastically from dog to dog — even within each breed.

“Please don’t believe the Internet that there is a breed or some variety of breeds that are going to be safe for you,” says Dr. Robert Wood, director of pediatric allergy and immunology at the Johns Hopkins Children’s Center, “because that clearly is not the case.”

Several studies have shown a tremendous variability of allergen levels, even within breeds, Woods says. One study published in the journal Allergy in 2005 found that poodles had a huge range in the amount of allergen dander found in individual dogs. One poodle was a very low allergen producer, while another produced 60 times more allergens — almost the highest of all the breeds tested.

One solution is to find a flexible breeder or shelter and take a dog home on trial. Wood says an allergy sufferer should be able to tell within two weeks whether the dog will trigger a reaction.

Sorry, but my allergist says that I’m probably the most dog-allergic person he has ever met. I didn’t think I’d ever be able to get a dog, BUT the Bichon Frise turned out to be my miracle pet! I know Obama thinks it a “girly” dog, but believe me he is anything but that! He is extremely energetic, comical, loyal, doesn’t shed, and DOES NOT SMELL like a dog even when wet! He should really reconsider and there are websites for rescued Bichon Frise dogs that would love a good home!

I have several purbred, papered dogs. All but one came from a rescue. Look to breed-specific rescues if you want to adopt a purered. Lots of people (too many) buy purebred and then turn the dog into rescue. To say one chooses between a purebred from a breeder and an all-American mutt is just naive.

Interesting article, but the author should understand that the AKC is NOT an unbiased source.

First off, ALL purebred dogs are “designed.” The most “designed” dogs are the purebred ones, which were created by breeding a dog with her child, grandchild, great grandchild, etc. This kind of indbreeding is destructive to the overall health of a species, is avoided by wildlife conservation biologists, and would be illegal if practiced in humans.

The fact of the matter is, non-purebred dogs, such as labradoodles, are less “designed” than inbred (or purebred, if you will) dogs. They are not as genetically predictable because some amount of natural genetic variation is embraced, rather than being stamped out. This kind of variation is more in keeping with everything we know about biology and genetic health.

The AKC is rigorously against any kind of interbreeding, and has adopted a system of “pure” breeds that guarantees extensive amounts of destructive inbreeding will continue. Their system is based on eugenic principles. Dogs have been bred for thousands of years, but only for the last couple hundred have breeders adopted such stringent eugenic principles.

It is therefore no surprise that the AKC would caution against a labradoodle. It’s true, different labradoodles have different coats and they are therefore less “predictable” in a sense. Labradoodls also have different personalities, temperments, etc. because they are not inbred. However, if the Obamas are going to get a rescue dog, then they will already know what the dog’s coat is like before they adopt the dog, so the AKC’s “reason” for avoiding a labradoodle falls apart.

I hope that they choose a rescue dog above all other considerations.

Barbara, Florida, USA January 11, 2009 · 4:14 pm

I think standard poodle advocates are on the right track. My brother-in-law (a self-styled redneck) inherited one through his wife, who had nursed a senior citizen. Duke was of champion stock, but had a sensible hunting haircut and loved riding in a golf cart. My brother-in-law’s fears of a “foo-foo” dog were overcome, and folks from infancy though 80 felt comfortable with Duke.

If the Obamas want a “hypo allergenic” dog, they should get a poodle (standard, mini or toy) from a rescue service. We adopted a toy poodle, and she is pure joy, with the personality of a big dog. Plus — NO SMELL. Even the cat likes her.

We have a Goldendoodle. Love her to pieces. We recently started agility training and she is doing very well. Highly recommend the mix. Does not shed. Loves people and other dogs. Just great.